Comments on: Best Sugar Free Gluten Free Low Carb Keto Eggnog Pie https://www.sugarfreemom.com/recipes/sugar-free-keto-eggnog-pie-low-carb-gluten-free-nut-free/ Naturally Sweetened Sugar-Free, Keto, Low Carb Recipes for the whole family. Wed, 21 Jan 2026 13:03:34 +0000 hourly 1 By: Brenda Bennett https://www.sugarfreemom.com/recipes/sugar-free-keto-eggnog-pie-low-carb-gluten-free-nut-free/comment-page-1/#comment-967687 Wed, 21 Jan 2026 13:03:34 +0000 https://www.sugarfreemom.com/?p=59494#comment-967687 In reply to Kerry.

Thanks! Hope they loved it!

]]> By: Kerry https://www.sugarfreemom.com/recipes/sugar-free-keto-eggnog-pie-low-carb-gluten-free-nut-free/comment-page-1/#comment-967647 Tue, 20 Jan 2026 21:10:21 +0000 https://www.sugarfreemom.com/?p=59494#comment-967647 5 stars
I had my doubts as filling seemed runny in pouring it into the pie crust. But it set up beautifully and tastes wonderful. Wished I had had rum extract but used vanilla. Still good. I will take it to a dinner tomorrow. Hope they like it. I used a pie crust from All Day I Dream About Food. I will top pie with cool whip as its more stable. Thanks for the recipe!

]]> By: Kate https://www.sugarfreemom.com/recipes/sugar-free-keto-eggnog-pie-low-carb-gluten-free-nut-free/comment-page-1/#comment-944484 Thu, 19 Dec 2024 04:54:19 +0000 https://www.sugarfreemom.com/?p=59494#comment-944484 In reply to Kate.

FYI This also freezes well! I was hesitant to try to freeze it because of the gelatin, but I froze the last couple of spices and there were no issues. Making this again this year so I thought I would pop by and add that in 🙂

]]> By: Brenda https://www.sugarfreemom.com/recipes/sugar-free-keto-eggnog-pie-low-carb-gluten-free-nut-free/comment-page-1/#comment-906498 Sat, 23 Dec 2023 13:35:07 +0000 https://www.sugarfreemom.com/?p=59494#comment-906498 In reply to Kate.

Amazing and thanks for sharing your dairy free swaps!

]]> By: Kate https://www.sugarfreemom.com/recipes/sugar-free-keto-eggnog-pie-low-carb-gluten-free-nut-free/comment-page-1/#comment-906486 Sat, 23 Dec 2023 00:01:23 +0000 https://www.sugarfreemom.com/?p=59494#comment-906486 5 stars
Great pie! Just be sure to taste the eggnog beforehand and adjust it to your taste. I like a strong eggnog flavor, that isn’t too boozy, and is nice and sweet. For this recipe that meant I added: 3/4 tsp nutmeg, 2 tsp rum extract instead of the rum, 1 1/2 tsp vanilla extract, and about 2 1/2 Tbsp extra sweetness.

I didn’t have liquid vanilla stevia so I used monk fruit extract powder (about 1/4 cup sweetness is the equivalent to the stevia) and 1/4 tsp vanilla extract.

I also made mine dairy free by using ripple heavy cream (emulsify together 2/3 cup ripple Unsweet and 1/3 cup neutral oil; soy milk also works) and added it only after the coconut milk came off of the boil. As well as added in 1/4 tsp xanthan gum once in the blender to make sure it set up well, as non dairy milks can be harder to set.
I also used Violife dairy free cream cheese, and chilled the eggnog mixture before adding it in, so it wouldn’t melt. All set up wonderfully.

This does dirty a lot of dishes but I enjoyed the result. Even better with some whipped cream on top!

]]> By: Stephanie https://www.sugarfreemom.com/recipes/sugar-free-keto-eggnog-pie-low-carb-gluten-free-nut-free/comment-page-1/#comment-896707 Sat, 02 Dec 2023 02:46:18 +0000 https://www.sugarfreemom.com/?p=59494#comment-896707 What can you use in place of the rum or rum extract?

]]> By: Brenda https://www.sugarfreemom.com/recipes/sugar-free-keto-eggnog-pie-low-carb-gluten-free-nut-free/comment-page-1/#comment-803263 Thu, 29 Dec 2022 01:51:13 +0000 https://www.sugarfreemom.com/?p=59494#comment-803263 In reply to Christie.

Answered that question right in the blog post.

]]> By: Christie https://www.sugarfreemom.com/recipes/sugar-free-keto-eggnog-pie-low-carb-gluten-free-nut-free/comment-page-1/#comment-803262 Thu, 29 Dec 2022 01:22:00 +0000 https://www.sugarfreemom.com/?p=59494#comment-803262 In reply to monika.

Can I just use store bought eggnog? Will this still set up? This sounds delicious!

]]> By: monika https://www.sugarfreemom.com/recipes/sugar-free-keto-eggnog-pie-low-carb-gluten-free-nut-free/comment-page-1/#comment-803247 Tue, 27 Dec 2022 18:53:01 +0000 https://www.sugarfreemom.com/?p=59494#comment-803247 5 stars
Can I use all coconut milk and skip the heavy cream? Will it still set up properly?

]]> By: Brenda https://www.sugarfreemom.com/recipes/sugar-free-keto-eggnog-pie-low-carb-gluten-free-nut-free/comment-page-1/#comment-803244 Tue, 27 Dec 2022 16:06:22 +0000 https://www.sugarfreemom.com/?p=59494#comment-803244 In reply to C NICOLE Gaines.

yes

]]> By: C NICOLE Gaines https://www.sugarfreemom.com/recipes/sugar-free-keto-eggnog-pie-low-carb-gluten-free-nut-free/comment-page-1/#comment-803241 Tue, 27 Dec 2022 13:50:26 +0000 https://www.sugarfreemom.com/?p=59494#comment-803241 Can I use all heavy cream and skip the coconut milk?

]]>