Crock Pot Cheese Stuffed Turkey Meatballs in homemade marinara sauce is a family favorite in my house and perfect for a busy school night dinner! These are made grain free, low carb, keto, and gluten free!
How to Make Turkey Meatballs
You may or may not be in love with your crock pot. If you have been scarred from one too many dry dinner recipes that made you feel like you could never trust it anymore, I can relate. I’ve been there too.
But given the right balance of time and liquids and you’ve got a winning recipe for the family.
This is my favorite way to add flavor to a somewhat bland kind of meat, ground turkey. The addition of spices and stuffed with cheese, slow cooked in a homemade marinara make this a recipe your family will ask you for often.
Slow Cooker or Baked Turkey Meatballs
Everyone loves meatballs so stuffing them with cheese was just something that had to happen in my opinion.We are a family of cheese lovers. I’ve made this recipe with both mozzarella and fontina, both equally delicious. The fontina is a bit more ooey gooey as you will see from the pics.
I’ve added directions to bake in the oven if you don’t have a slow cooker. Either way is delicious!
This recipe makes 2 dozen so you should have enough left overs as well.
Warning: If you have a boy teenager in the house, like my son, you may not have much left over at all. My own son, who after having been sick for a week barely eating, enjoyed about 8 of these the first night his appetite was back. True story.
Other fabulous Slow Cooker Meals to feed the whole family:
Moral of today:
If you’re ready to love your crock pot again and make peace with it if it has failed you terribly in the past, this recipe is the one that will help you make amends. 🙂
If you like this recipe, you’ll find many more in my Meal Plan Membership.
Crock Pot Turkey Meatballs
Remember to subscribe to the Sugar Free Mom Newsletter for free and receive fresh recipe notifications delivered into your inbox!
If you try a recipe, please use the hashtag #sugarfreemom on instagram for a chance to be featured! Follow Sugar Free Mom on Facebook | Instagram | Pinterest | Twitter for all of the latest content, recipes and updates.
Crock Pot Cheese Stuffed Turkey Meatballs
Ingredients
- 2 eggs
- 1/2 cup pork rinds crushed
- 1/2 cup Parmesan cheese grated
- 2 tablespoons Italian seasonings
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 1/2 teaspoon pepper
- 1/2 teaspoon garlic powder
- 2 1/2 pounds ground turkey
- 8 ounces Fontina cheese cut into 24 pieces or mozzarella
Marinara Sauce
- 28 ounce crushed tomatoes
- 2 teaspoons minced garlic
- 1 tablespoon extra virgin olive oil
- 2 teaspoons dried basil
- 1 teaspoon dried parsley
- 1 teaspoon salt
- 1/2 teaspoon pepper
Instructions
Crock Pot Directions
-
In a large bowl whisk the eggs, pork rinds, cheese and seasonings together.
-
Add the ground turkey and mix just until combined.
-
Roll mixture into 24 meatballs.
-
Insert 1 cube of cheese into the center of each meatball. Set aside.
-
In a separate bowl stir together the marinara sauce ingredients.
-
Pour enough sauce to cover the bottom of the crock pot.
-
Place meatballs in the crock pot and cover with remaining sauce.
-
Cover and cook on high 3 hours or low 6 hours.
Oven Directions
-
Follow the recipe up until you put the sauce in the crock pot. Instead place half the sauce into a 9 by 13 baking pan. Add all the meatballs and cover with remaining sauce. Bake 30 minutes or until turkey is no longer pink when cut open.
Recipe Notes
Net Carbs: 7g
This recipe was first published in September 2014 and updated with video in January 2019.
We are also a family of cheese-lovers…I don’t know which I want to try more, the fontina or the mozzarella. I think I’d have to go half and half! And since I do have a teenage boy in the house (and a swimmer, at that), I think these would be the perfect dinner.
So much goodness stuffed into these meatballs – and the fact that you can make them in a crock pot makes them even better!
I love that you made these in the crock pot!!! And that cheese…..oh.boy. 🙂
You just can’t go wrong with a stuffed meatball. I love that you used two kinds of cheeses and ground turkey. I’m going to pin your recipe and hopefully try it very soon. It look like something my family will really enjoy!
Thanks for pinning!
Yeah I’ve been burned by my crock pot a time or two LOL I am willing to give it another try though! I love the Fontina cheese used here – that’s actually my favorite cheese ever.
I used to have a love/hate relationship with mine. Then I realized that my crock just cooks a lot “hotter” than others. Once I realized how to adjust the cooking time, I fell back in love. These meatballs look amazing and fontina is by far my favorite cheese!
I don’t know why I never bake meatballs in my slow-cooker…wow! This is the recipe I will make next! My kids will be delighted:)
I LOVE this! I am making a stock of slow cooker recipes and I am definitely making this one!
This actually looks like a fun recipe to put together. Love that it can go in the slow cooker too. I LOVE my crock pot.
I just made this and was super delicioso
Wow You are fast!! Glad you liked them!
I LOVE using my crock pot and these are just begging for me to make them. Thanks for the great recipe!
Brenda, it was so good to see you again. . um, hello?! love these meatballs!!! I can’t believe I’ve never made meatballs in my slow cooker!!! It’s my fave appliance in the fall. . love this and pinned!
So nice seeing and chatting with you this weekend Alice!! Thanks for pinning too!
These look so delicious. My daughter would be thrilled with the cheese in the middle.
Oh my heavens – slow cooked in a crockpot and with cheese inside? Love this meatball recipe!
OMG! These meatballs are a treat!
This is divine. I want to run right into my kitchen right this minute and whip this up.
Cheese stuffed meatballs! Yes please!
They look awesome! I have made stuffed meatballs before but never in the crockpot.
I grew up eating cheese stuffed meatballs and I can’t believe I don’t make them often. They are the best and this recipes sounds so much better. I should try it!
I could not find fontina cheese. Would swiss, cheddar or cream cheese be a good alternative?
Mozzarella would work. I wouldn’t use Swiss myself, not a fan. Cheddar would be fine too.
These were amazing! Found Fontina at Kroger and Food Lion. The kids and the hubby said,
“Make these again” — with my newly found, sugar free marinara recipe. Thank you, thank you, thank you!
This was so amazing, my daughter and hubby loved them! Sooo good!
Hello, I’m curious on the carb content, I did not see it listed on the nutrition list. Thank you.
Sorry the plug in I switched to is not working properly. I will need to get back to you on that.
Total Carbs: 4.5g
Dietary Fiber: 0.6g
Net Carbs: 3.9g per serving
Wow!! I made this because I had the ground turkey and didn’t have a recipe. I had to change the oats to quinoa because I’m Celiac and they were totally delicious!! I also didn’t have time to put them in the crock pot and just browned them in the frying pan and poured the sauce over top and let it simmer for a few minutes. I don’t think I’ll ever eat ground beef again!! Thanks again!!
So, it says you cook on low for 6hours, but the total cook time at the top says 8hrs w 20 min prep? And since I’m new to this …so you just mix the packaged turkey with the ingredients and roll into balls then it cooks thoroughly through out the meatballs?
I just switched my recipe plug in and I’m finding a few errors when it was converting recipes to the new plug in. This is one of them as well as making all my serving sizes crazy unrealistic like 1 gram! Anyway, I updated the time issue here, thanks for letting me know. Yes make the meatballs, roll them up, add to crock pot.
Thank you so much!!! The kids can’t wait….Dad is being Mr mom now. Lol…
These are amazing!!! Easy and very tasty! I can’t wait to make them again!
What else could you sub for the oats to keep it Keto friendly?
Thanks,
Penny
I’d sub crushed pork rinds or just use more grated parmesan,
Made this it was delish. Even my unloving turkey son liked it.
Can we use ground chicken instead of turkey? Also, can I make thematic few days in advance and freeze beforehand?
Sure! And yes you can bake freeze then thaw when you want them.
I forgot the old fashioned oats at the store but have quick oats. Would those work?
sure
Hi Brenda ~ I’m not a fan of pork rinds. What else could I use in its place and still keep it Keto friendly.
Tx/Dolores
Try almond flour
Made these tonight after reading the post this morning. OUTSTANDING! Thank you for keeping the healthy ideas family friendly and recipes easy to make! The recipe is a repeat for this family!
These meatballs look sooo tasty! I love that they’re cheesed stuffed too. I’ll have to make this recipe soon, thank you!
I have a similar recipe like this where I use buffalo sauce and blue cheese. I never use them in the crock pot- I think I will now.
help!!!!! I don’t eat pork. at all!!! and every recipe depends on pork rinds….I can get around with almond flour and parmesan usually, but now what for meatballs?? help!!
Almond flour will work for these as well.
Can you use ground beef instead? If so should it be the same amount asTurkey? Thanks
Sure you can use ground beef, same amount.
It’s in my crockpot right now ! I put the rest of my crumbled pork skins on top , had to add salsa to the marina because I didn’t have enough crushed tomatoes.
It was very good! Will make again!
What can I sub for pork rinds? Almond flour? Would the measurement be the same?
Yes almond flour would work, same amount.
If I assemble and freeze couple days before and pop in crock pot while still frozen on a busy morning?
That should work.
I have this same recipe that I printed out a few months back, but it says 1/2 cup rolled oats and nothing about pork rinds.
Is there a reason the recipe changed? What is the pros of using pork rinds over the oats? Thanks!
Yes I swapped the rolled out to make this low carb by using the pork rinds. You can use either.