This Homemade Nutella is actually healthy, sugar-free, dairy free, low carb and made with only 5 ingredients!
Most everyone knows what Nutella is right? That hazelnut chocolate spread that you can buy pretty much purchase at any market. Commercials even advertise it as a great breakfast option on toast, really??!! I could never give it to my kids for breakfast it’s so full of sugar and one bite is surely addictive I tell ya! Talk about a sugar crash immediately after ingesting!
Before I became sugar free over 13 years ago now, I would buy the store bought brand and eat a spoonful a day, I’d finish off a jar a week! To say I wasn’t addictive is a lie for sure. The taste is unmistakable and there really isn’t anything else to compare with it. Today I can honestly say I have no interest to ever buy store bought Nutella again and making my homemade version is the next best thing. Knowing it’s sugar free, without preservatives and additives makes me super happy and you could most certainly have it for breakfast with some toast!
It’s super creamy with the addition of some coconut oil! I love making easy spreads like this in my Food Processor! One appliance to clean and your work is done in the kitchen! Other No Bake Recipes my family loves that can easily be made in your food processor are:
- No Bake Chocolate Protein Bites
- No Bake Coconut Cashew Protein Bars
- No Bake Chocolate Fudge Protein Bars
Yes it is a bit messy, but that’s the fun of it all!
Here’s my video showing how easy this is!
No need for refrigeration, it can stay at room temp for up to a week, if it even lasts that long.
Here are some other recipes you will enjoy using this homemade Nutella:
May not be as perfectly smooth as the store-bought kind, but for a homemade healthy sugar-free version there is no denying, it’s amazing!
Brenda’s Notes:
- If you’d prefer a thicker texture use 1/4 cup coconut oil melted. I prefer it to be more spreadable and loose so I used more oil. If you prefer thinner texture as in my pictures above use 1/2 cup coconut oil.
- The hazelnut flavored stevia is fantastic here, but feel free to use any sweetener you prefer to taste.
- If you prefer to leave all sweeteners out you can also do that and it will be more like a peanut butter that has no sugar in it.
- FYI: Because you are using melted coconut oil here it will look looser in texture once made, but set aside for a little while on counter or even refrigerate for 30 minutes and you will notice it thickens up. If you do refrigerate too long it will harden and not be spreadable so I suggest keeping it on the counter in a covered container.
- This recipe was originally posted in April of 2014 but I felt a short video was needed to bring this awesome recipe out of the archives!
Remember to subscribe to the Sugar Free Mom Newsletter for free and receive fresh recipe notifications delivered into your inbox!
If you try a recipe, please use the hashtag #sugarfreemom on instagram for a chance to be featured! Follow Sugar Free Mom on Facebook | Instagram | Pinterest | Twitter for all of the latest content, recipes and updates.
Sugar-Free Homemade Nutella
Ingredients
- 2 cups hazelnuts
- 1/4 cup coconut oil melted
- 6 tablespoons unsweetened cocoa powder
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 1/2-1 tsp liquid hazelnut stevia
Instructions
-
In a dry skillet, toast your hazelnuts until fragrant, about 4-5minutes over medium heat.
-
Place on a clean kitchen towel and allow to cool.
-
Once cool rub towel over them to loosen and remove as much of their skins as possible.
-
Place in a food processor or high powdered blender and process until fine crumbs.
-
Add remaining ingredients and blend until smooth.
-
Taste and adjust salt and stevia if needed.
-
Makes 12 ounces.
Recipe Notes
Net Carbs: 1g
Sugar runs through my veins (thanks, Dad!), but I would have no problem eating this version, too!
Still just as chocolatey and sweet tasting. 🙂
I’m intrigued. We are absolutely nutty for Nutella.
Thanks, hope you’ll try it.
Homemade is always better than store bought! This looks delicious!
Thank you!
I love me some good homemade nutella!
Thanks, it has finally been crossed of my foodie to do list!
What a great idea to make homemade Nutella!
It precedes many more recipes coming that include it this homemade recipe. 🙂
WOW! You have made my day and this chocolate lover very happy! Thanks for sharing!
Thanks Andy!
On my list to make. Got a bag of hazelnut meal fro mBob’s Red Mill. Already less work for my food processor.:) Pinned.
Did using the hazelnut meal work out okay?
What a great solution to healthi-fy Nutella! 😀
For me, it’s the only way I can enjoy “nutella”.
This just might be a perfect treat for my kids, but since they were all recently diagnosed with candida, I was wonderding whether cocoa is allowed their list? Thanks
My goodness I need this in my life! I LOVE hazelnut stevia- love it! Plus anything with coconut oil and chocolate is a win:) THANKS FOR THE RECIPE!
Wow, I am seriously impressed! What an awesome recipe. This could definitely cure a craving or…. ten, love that it’s something I can enjoy without the guilt.. or ruining my strict diet. I pinned this yesterday for safe keeping. YUM!
Oh, this would be dangerous info at my house! I can’t wait to try this out so I can have Nutella all.the.time lol!
What other sweetner can I used besides stevia? Would honey or maple syrup work?
of course, use whichever you like. You’ll have to add a small amount and taste and adjust to your liking.
I used 1/2 cup of Swerve Confectioners. It is sweet because my daughter likes it that way, you could try less if you like. It worked well. – I also added 1/2 tsp vanilla essence.
Hi Brenda!
I know! I can’t believe they advertise nutella as being a healthy breakfast choice for your children! I loved it as a kid though, and that’s why I make it homemade now. I have a recipe on my site that is very similar to yours, but I use either honey or pure maple syrup and it comes out great!
Those gloopy gooey nutella-y pictures look sooooo good!
Will you taste the coconut oil? I simply dislike that taste and am wondering if you will taste it do you have any suggestions for a substitute?
No not at all, the hazelnuts overpower the oil.
What if allergic to coconut? Do you have a replacement suggestion?
Maybe use butter instead or avocado oil.
Looks amazing!!!!! But I can’t have coconut oil is there anything that you can substitute it with to make this deliciousness??
Someone mentioned using hazelnut flour….will that work okay?
I’ve never used hazelnut flour so I can’t say for sure, sorry.
This came out horrible.
There is too much salt in it, I ended up throwing it to the bin.
Mine was super dry tasting and the hazelnuts were way overpowering. I used the exact same ingredients, plus a little extra coconut oil because it was too thick. Does anyone have a fix?
Hello, I want to make this for my daughter and she doesn’t need to be sugar free, what quantity of sugar or glucose or something else would you suggest as a sub for the Stevia? Many thanks x
Love love love this stuff! Admittedly, not as smooth as Nutella but nowt wrong with Chunky Nuttella .
If you boiled hazelnut in baking soda for few min- few min than skin will come off very very easy.
I’m also adding 1 tbs of amaretto (just for extra flavor)
My daughter is allergic to anything coconut. What other oil can I substitute? Would Grapeseed oil work? OR ??
Thank you…can’t wait to make this for her…hey…for us too! 🙂
Have you tried mixing your favorite nut butter with NuNaturals Cocoa Syrup? It makes a great chocolate spread and SO easy. https://www.nunaturals.com/product/665
I am addicted to chocolate. Unfortunately I just became diabetic. This is a great option! Thank you
Oh, my gosh, mine turned out chalky. I have five pounds of hazelnuts to process for Christmas gifts. What am I gonna do??!! I made my first batch of 2 cups and it is really not satisfactory? Any suggestions?
I’m not sure why the chalky texture. Maybe you need a bit more coconut oil. Did you remove the skins after toasting them?
Yes, I did remove the skins. I actually think that I toasted them too long. They ended up being pretty dry. I don’t know why I thought that the recipe would magically change that. I am going to try, again, today, and be more careful about the toasting process. Thanks.
I made too much, can you freeze this?
sure
Hi BRENDA!! This looks great but where do you buy HAZLENUT LIQUID STEVIA?? Thx!
The link to buy it on Amazon is right in the ingredients list, just click that.
Quick question – your notes say “If you’d prefer a thicker texture start with only 1/4 cup coconut oil melted and then add more for the consistency you’d like. I prefer it to be more spreadable and loose and used the amount below in the recipe.” I’m confused because the recipe lists 1/4 cup coconut oil. Is that the amount you used for the looser version, or is that the amount I should use for a thicker texture? Thank you! Can’t wait to try this!
Sorry about that if you want a looser texture use up to 1/2 cup coconut oil.
I have some ground hazelnut already ground with the peels on it, can I use that or not?
yes
How long is the shelf life for this?
I kept mine refrigerated for 2 weeks and just microwaved it for 20 seconds to be able to spread.
Hello! Can I use sugar free hazelnut syrup in place of hazelnut stevia? Thank you
You could but not sure how much, just add a small amount and taste and adjust.
THANKS! All I have to do is buy the hazelnuts now. I’ll let you know how it turns out. 😋
Do you know if the same measurement applies if you use cacao instead of cocoa? Thanks so much!
Yes same measurement.
I made this. It is awful. I followed the instructions to the letter. It is so bitter! I added Hazelnut Stevia, I added plain Stevia. I even added a touch of vanilla. It is still awful. Any suggestions? I miss Nutella and I want this to work.
If it’s still bitter, your taste buds require more sweetness. You could add some confectioners Swerve and the same amount of stevia, which might help balance the flavors for you.
Nothing short of dreadful. What a waste of time and effort. The stevia leaves such a horrible aftertaste and the consistency is like damp sand. In fact, I think sand may taste better. Straight to the bin…